|  
                
   
    | 
        
  
    | A DYNAMIC, COMPLEX AND UNPREDICTABLE WORLD: Its impact on the international, global and regional trade agenda.
 |  
   
    | by Félix PeñaJanuary 2018
 
 English translation: Isabel Romero Carranza
 |   
    |  |  
   
    |    | The idea that the world of the upcoming years will 
        continue to be dynamic, complex and unpredictable was mentioned in our 
        newsletter of last December. We added that perhaps it would be much more 
        so than in recent years and that this will have an impact on international 
        commercial relations. From there, we concluded that all countries, including 
        Argentina, would need to have the ability to identify and assess all feasible 
        options for their international commercial insertion strategy. 
       The annual meeting of the World Economic Forum (WEF) that will take 
        place in Davos-Klosters (Switzerland) on 22 to 26 January will be held 
        with the central theme of "Creating a shared future in a fractured 
        world".  This idea of acting together in a divided world, evokes the regional 
        strategic approach of "convergence in diversity" promoted in 
        Latin America by the Foreign Minister of Chile, Heraldo Muñoz, 
        at the beginning of the government of President Michelle Bachelet. It continues to be a valid strategic approach for the region, especially 
        to realize the political will to promote a greater articulation between 
        different integration processes, particularly between Mercosur and the 
        Pacific Alliance. Moreover, this strategic approach can lead to strengthening 
        existing institutional frameworks in the Latin American region, especially 
        that of LAIA.  However, the idea of "Creating a shared future in a fractured 
        world" gives special importance to the November G20 Summit of Buenos 
        Aires. The problems of international governance that are becoming evident 
        -and that have a notorious epicenter in the international trade arena-will 
        require a special effort to build the necessary consensus among the member 
        countries and to irradiate them to the rest of the world. This relevance 
        is reflected in the vision of the Argentine Presidency in the G20-2018 
        entitled "Building Consensus for Fair and Sustainable Development".
 Davos is an opportunity to convey the vision of political leaders on relevant 
        issues of the global agenda. President Mauricio Macri will participate 
        and will have the opportunity to present his vision on the role that the 
        G20 can play in relation to relevant issues of international governance 
        and, in particular, the governance of the global system of world trade. 
        The Buenos Aires presidential declaration of the WTO Ministerial Conference 
        will allow President Macri to invoke the consensus reached on such issues 
        between Latin American countries and, especially, among the members of 
        the Pacific Alliance and Mercosur.
 
 
 IN MEMORIAM I dedicate these reflections to a great teacher and friend, Professor 
        Jean-Pierre Lehmann. He passed away in Lausanne, on December 21. He was 
        Professor Emeritus at IMD Lausanne and founder of the Evian Group. He 
        participated as a special guest in the INTAL-CAF-CARI-FICBC meeting on 
        the WTO Ministerial, which took place in Buenos Aires on December 10 (he 
        had to do it remotely since his health condition prevented him from travelling). 
        Some of his latest publications are listed as recommended reading of this 
        newsletter, including his piece on the WTO, published on March 16 in the 
        South China Morning Post. For his full biography go to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean-Pierre_Lehmann. 
          |  
   
    |  On January 2 of this year, Ian Bremmer and Cliff Kupchan, President 
        and Chairman respectively, began the annual report of the Eurasia Group, 
        entitled "Top Risks 2018", by pointing out: "Let's be honest: 
        2018 doesn't feel good. Yes, markets are soaring and the economy isn't 
        bad, but citizens are divided. Governments aren't doing much governing. 
        And the global order is unraveling"
then they added: "if 
        we had to pick one year for a big unexpected crisis -the geopolitical 
        equivalent of the 2008 financial meltdown- it feels like 2018. Sorry...we 
        now see more clearly a world without leadership". They concluded 
        their introduction by mentioning: "Concerns about the prospects of 
        a geopolitical depression form the backdrop for our top ten risks this 
        year". (For the full 
        report in English go to https://www.eurasiagroup.net/). 
       In turn, Malcolm Turnbull, the Prime Minister of Australia, began the 
        presentation of his government's White Paper on Australia's Foreign Policy 
        noting that: "Change, unprecedented in its scale and pace, is the 
        tenor of our times. These are the most exciting times, the times of greatest 
        opportunity, but they are also times of uncertainty, of risk, indeed of 
        danger". (For the full text in English of the 2017 
        Foreign Policy White Paper-Australian Government of November 22, 2017, 
        go to https://www.fpwhitepaper.gov.au/). 
       Coinciding with many other analysts, the idea that the world of the next 
        years will continue to be dynamic, complex and unpredictable, was also 
        present in our newsletter of last December. We added that perhaps it would 
        be much more so than in recent years and that this will have a strong 
        impact on international commercial relations.  From there, we concluded that all countries, including Argentina, would 
        need to have the ability to identify and assess all feasible options for 
        their international commercial insertion strategy. This will require something 
        that has not always abounded in our ideas about the country's international 
        insertion, which is the need to reconcile, simultaneously, short-term 
        visions and interests with those of the very long term. Moreover, it will 
        require the ability to grasp and anticipate, in due time, the continuous 
        displacements of competitive advantages between nations and firms, originated 
        in technological changes, in variations of relative power of the protagonists, 
        or in cultural transformations that affect the values and priorities of 
        consumers (see the December 2017 edition of this newsletter, entitled: 
        "A 
        complex and inevitable transition: Towards a new stage in international 
        commercial relations?", on http://www.felixpena.com.ar/). 
       The annual meeting of the World Economic Forum (Davos-Klosters, Switzerland) 
        to be held from January 22 to 26 will have the central theme of "Creating 
        a shared future in a fractured world". It will bring together political, 
        economic and social leaders from different countries, as well as experts 
        and opinion formers.  The WEF meeting's announcement points out that: "The global context 
        has changed dramatically: geostrategic fissures have re-emerged on multiple 
        fronts with wide-ranging political, economic and social consequences. 
        Realpolitik is no longer just a relic of the Cold War. Economic prosperity 
        and social cohesion are not the same. The global commons cannot protect 
        or heal themselves". It continues by adding: "Politically, new 
        and divisive narratives are transforming governance. Economically, policies 
        are being formulated to preserve the benefits of global integration while 
        limiting shared obligations such as sustainable development, inclusive 
        growth and managing the Fourth Industrial Revolution. Socially, citizens 
        yearn for responsive leadership; yet, a collective purpose remains elusive 
        despite ever-expanding social networks. All the while, the social contract 
        between states and their citizens continues to erode". Finally, it 
        states that: "The 48th World Economic Forum Annual Meeting therefore 
        aims to rededicate leaders from all walks of life to developing a shared 
        narrative to improve the state of the world. The program, initiatives 
        and projects of the meeting are focused on Creating a Shared Future in 
        a Fractured World. By coming together at the start of the year, we can 
        shape the future by joining this unparalleled global effort in co-design, 
        co-creation and collaboration. The program's depth and breadth make it 
        a true summit of summits".  This idea of acting together in a divided world evokes the regional strategic 
        approach of "convergence in diversity", promoted in Latin America 
        by the Foreign Minister of Chile, Heraldo Muñoz, at the beginning 
        of the government of President Michelle Bachelet. (Refer to the July 
        2014 edition of this newsletter and the December 
        2014 edition on http://www.felixpena.com.ar/). It continues to be 
        a valid strategic approach for the region, especially to realize the political 
        will to promote a greater articulation between the different integration 
        processes and, especially, between Mercosur and the Pacific Alliance. It is, moreover, a strategic approach that can lead to strengthening 
        existing institutional frameworks in the Latin American region and, in 
        particular, that of LAIA. (On this topic, see the March 
        2017 edition of this newslette, and the July 
        2017 edition, on http://www.felixpena.com.ar/). The idea of "Creating a shared future in a fractured world" 
        gives special importance to the November G20 Summit of Buenos Aires. The 
        problems of international governance, which are becoming evident and that 
        have a notorious epicenter at the international trade level (see our newsletter 
        of last December), will require a special effort to build the necessary 
        consensus among the member countries. It was precisely the need to have 
        a functional political ambit to build consensus on international governance 
        what originated, in the middle of the deep financial crisis of 2008, the 
        first meeting of the G20 Summit at the level of Heads of State, not just 
        of Finance Ministers and Presidents of Central Banks as it had been until 
        then. Thus, geopolitics entered fully into the agendas of the G20.  This relevance is reflected in the vision of the Argentine Presidency 
        in the G20 - 2018, entitled "Building Consensus for Fair and Sustainable 
        Development". At the beginning of his term in charge of the Presidency 
        of the G20, in December of last year, President Mauricio Macri pointed 
        out that: "We are proud to have this opportunity to show our commitment 
        to international cooperation, multilateralism and global governance". 
        He also added: "We will steer the G20's efforts throughout our presidency 
        in the spirit of an honest broker". (For the full text of the document 
        on the vision of the Argentine Presidency of the G20 - 2018, go to https://g20.org/. 
        The English version can be found on https://www.g20.org/). 
       As noted above, the WEF in Davos is an opportunity to convey the vision 
        of political leaders on relevant issues of the global agenda. President 
        Xi Jinping did so when he spoke in 2017 (see the text of his presentation 
        on https://america.cgtn.com/). 
        President Donald Trump will speak this year. Given the position of his 
        government on relevant issues of the governance of the global system of 
        world trade, it is logical to imagine that his speech will be analyzed 
        with strong interest.  Also participating will be President Mauricio Macri, who will then have 
        an opportunity to present his vision on the role that the G20 can play 
        in relation to relevant issues of international governance and, in particular, 
        on the governance of the global system of world trade. The Buenos Aires 
        presidential declaration will allow President Macri to invoke the consensus 
        that has already been reached on such issues between Latin American countries 
        and, especially among those who are members of the Pacific Alliance and 
        of Mercosur. (For the text of the presidential declaration at the opening 
        of the Eleventh WTO Ministerial Conference, go to https://www.wto.org/). |  
   
    | 
        Aragón, Pablo, "Mercosur y sus fantasías. Un acuerdo 
          entre la UE y el Mercosur de libre comercio es muy improbable para 2018", 
          en "El Observador", sección Opinión, Montevideo, 
          enero 8 de 2018, en https://www.elobservador.com.uy/. 
          
Barbosa, Rubens, "O Brasil e as Perspectivas Globais para 2018", 
          jornal "O Estado de Sâo Paulo", 9 de janeiro 2018. 
Camroux, David, "Is Trump's America the "dispensable" 
          power in Asia", East Asia Forum, 31 December 2017, en http://www.eastasiaforum.org/. 
          
El Observador, "La opción de salir del Mercosur. Abrirse 
          del bloque regional es un camino razonable pero no fácil de emprender"", 
          Editorial, "El Observador", Montevideo, enero 2, 2018, en 
          . https://www.elobservador.com.uy/. 
          
Eurasia Group, "Top Risks 2018", Ian Bremmer, President 
          and Cliff Kupchan, Chairman, 2 January 2018, en https://www.eurasiagroup.net/. 
          
Ferguson, Niall, "The Square and the Tower. Nertorks, Hierarchies 
          and the Struggle for Global Power", Penguin Random House, 2017.
Gasparré, Dardo, "¿Y si nos vamos todos del Mercosur" 
          Lo que le convendría a los países fundadores es irse del 
          Mercosur, un extremo que muestra la inviabilidad de cambiar su proteccionismo", 
          en "El Observador", sección Opinión, Montevideo, 
          enero 9 de 2018, en https://www.elobservador.com.uy/. 
          
Glossrman, Brad, "Trump thumps the WTO", East Asia Forum, 
          10 January 2018, en http://www.eastasiaforum.org/. 
          
Goh, Evelyn; Reilly, James, "How China's Belt and Road builds 
          connections", East Asia Foum, 4 January 2018, en http://www.eastasiaforum.org/. 
          
Held, David; Roger, Charles (eds.). "Global Governance at Risk", 
          Polity Press, Cambridge - Malden, 2013.
Holbraad, Carsten, "Middle Powers in International Politics", 
          St.Martin's Press, New York 1984. Versión en español, 
          "Las Potencias Medias en la Política Internacional", 
          Fondo de Cultura Económica 1989.
Iglesias, Enrique V., "Reflexiones sobre la coyuntura internacional 
          y regional", en revista "Estudios Internacionales", Instituto 
          de Estudios Internacionales - Universidad de Chile, Volumen 49, Edición 
          Especial 50 Años, Santiago de Chile 2017, ps. 39 a 47, en https://revistaei.uchile.cl/. 
          
IRI, "Revista de Relaciones Internacionales", Instituto 
          de Relaciones Internacionales - Universidad de la Plata, Año 
          26 - Nª 53, Julio/Diciembre 2017, en http://www.iri.edu.ar.
Nayyar, Dhiraj, "Why India and China must take the lead in the 
          Asia century", East Asia Forum, 7 January 2018, en http://www.eastasiaforum.org/. 
          
Lafer, Celso, "Em defesa da OMC. Não identifico boa-fé 
          na diplomacia de combate ao multilateralismo do governo de Trump", 
          Jornal "O Estado de Sâo Paulo", 17 de dezembro 2017, 
          en http://opiniao.estadao.com.br/. 
          
Legro, Jeffery W., "Rethinking the World. Great Power Strategies 
          and International Order", Cornell University Press, Ithaca and 
          London, 2005.
Lehmann, Jean-Pierre, "A revived WTO offers the best defence 
          against Donald Trump's assault on trade", "South China Morning 
          Post, Edition International, 16 March 2017, en http://www.scmp.com/. 
          
Lehmann, Jean-Pierre, "The global order is crumbling and we need 
          a fix to curb humanity's worst instincts", South China Morning 
          Post, Edition International, 12 April 2017, en http://www.scmp.com/.
Lehmann, Jean-Pierre, Why the West and Japan should stop preaching 
          to a rising China", South China Morning Post, Edition International, 
          6 July 2017, en http://www.scmp.com/. 
          
Lehmann, Jean-Pierre, "Why the world has to study Chinese history, 
          and how China views history", South China Morning Post, Edition 
          International, 8 August 2017, en http://www.scmp.com/. 
          En español en http://historiaglobalonline.com/. 
          
Lehmann, Jean-Pierre, "A trade war is imminent, but not inevitable. 
          Can mindsets change before it's too late?", South China Morning 
          Post, Edition International, 8 Septermber 2017, en http://www.scmp.com/
Lehmann, Jean-Pierre, "China's rise is assured in our new world 
          order, but not as a hegemon", South China Morning Post, Edition 
          International, 13 October 2017, en http://www.scmp.com/. 
          
Lehmann, Jean-Pierre, "Why fears over a malign China replacing 
          a benign America are a gross distortion of history", South China 
          Morning Post, Edition International, 13 November 2017, en http://www.scmp.com/. 
          
Lieven, Anatol, "America Right or Wrong: An Anatomy of American 
          Nationalism", Oxford University Press, Oxford - New York, 2004.
Loaiza, Carlos, "Mercosur: trampa o trampoline. ¿Qué 
          impacto económio tiene realmente el bloque para nuestro país? 
          ¿Cabría acaso la posibilidad de un "Uruexit"?", 
          en "El Observador", Montevideo, diciembre 29, 2017, en https://www.elobservador.com.uy/. 
          
Ping, Jonathan H., "Middle Power Statecraft. Indonesia, Malaysia 
          and the Asia-Pacific", Routledge, London and New York, 2005-2018.
McCoy, Alfred W., "In the Shadows of the Americaan Century. The 
          Rise and Decline of US Global Power", DB Dispatch Books - Haymarket 
          Books, Chicargo 2017.
Morandé Lavin, José A., "Presentación", 
          Instituto de Estudios Internacionales, "Estudios Internacionales", 
          Revista del Instituto de Estudios Internacionales, Universidad de Chile, 
          Volumen 49, Edición Especial 50 Años, ps. 7 a 17, en https://revistaei.uchile.cl/. 
          
Nathan, Andrew J., "Self-interest shapes China's policies toward 
          the international", East Asia Forum, 19 December 2017, en http://www.eastasiaforum.org/. 
          
Osnos, Evan, "Making China Great Again. As Donald Trump surrender 
          America's global commitments, Xi Jinping is learning to pick up the 
          pieces", The New Yorks, January 8, 2918, en https://www.newyorker.com/. 
          
Peña, Felix, "América Latina en un mundo incierto 
          y turbulento: impacto sobre las estrategias de integración regional", 
          Instituto de Estudios Internacionales - Universidad de Chile, Volumen 
          49, Edición Especial 50 Años, Santiago de Chile 2017, 
          ps. 113 a 124, en https://revistaei.uchile.cl/. 
          
Perry World House, "The Future of the Global Order. In an era 
          of populism, nationalism, and retrenchment", Fall 2017 Colloquium 
          Report, Pennsylvania Pa., September 2017, en https://global.upenn.edu/. 
          
The White House, "National Security Strategy of the United States 
          of America", Washington DC. December 2017, en https://www.whitehouse.gov/. 
          
Torreblanca, José Ignacio, "La Casa Blanca ha caído", 
          diario "El País", 11 de enero, página 2, en 
          https://elpais.com/. 
          
Wolff, Michael, "Fire and Fury. Inside the Trump White House", 
          Henry Holt and Company, New York 2018. |  
   
    |  
        
 
   
    |  |   
    | Félix Peña Director 
        of the Institute of International Trade at the ICBC Foundation. Director 
        of the Masters Degree in International Trade Relations at Tres de Febrero 
        National University (UNTREF). Member of the Executive Committee of the 
        Argentine Council for International Relations (CARI). Member of the Evian 
        Group Brains Trust. More 
        information. |  
 
 |  |  |