|  
                
   
    | 
        
  
    | THE UNTAPPED POTENTIAL OF THE LAIA: Appropriate instruments for the convergence of Latin American diversity.
 |  
   
    | by Félix PeñaJune 2018
 
 English translation: Isabel Romero Carranza
 |   
    |  |  
   
    |    | The Latin American Integration Association (LAIA or 
        ALADI for its initials in Spanish) constitutes an institutional framework 
        that provides, on the one hand, legal coverage of preferential trade agreements 
        developed between all or some of its member countries, eventually promoting 
        them. On the other hand, it constitutes a space for interaction with other 
        countries in order to promote and facilitate, among other objectives, 
        the development of trade and economic complementation. This without prejudice 
        that, over time, they might have a scope that encompasses more general 
        and ambitious objectives (for example, a Latin American common market), 
        which may be extended to all Latin American countries. 
       For companies interested in building or participating in transnational 
        networks in the region covered by the LAIA, this institutional framework 
        can serve as a source of information on the preferential actions carried 
        out in the region, and also as an area to promote governmental agreements 
        (of regional or partial scope) that are functional to business objectives 
        in other countries of the region. 
 The instrument of the agreement of partial scope can then be functional 
        to the web of sectoral networks of complementation and productive integration. 
        For companies, especially SMEs, the partial scope agreements in their 
        economic complementation modality, may prove useful for their sector complementation 
        strategies with companies from other LAIA countries.
 The agreements of partial scope help achieve reasonable balances between 
        two sometimes contradictory demands, both of the companies and of the 
        governments. One is the demand for flexibility in the ground rules that 
        are applied to develop sectoral productive complementation strategies. 
        The other is the demand for predictability regarding the application of 
        the ground rules that are agreed in the corresponding partial scope agreement, 
        especially with regard to the stability of the conditions for market access. |  
   
    |  The potential of the Latin American Integration Association (LAIA) has 
        not yet been fully harnessed (http://www.aladi.org/sitioAladi/index.html). 
        Tapping into this potential does not necessarily depend on the collective 
        action of its member countries.  The LAIA was created in 1980 to replace the Latin American Free Trade 
        Association (LAFTA), which in turn had been created in 1960 in order to 
        develop a free trade zone that had to be perfected within a period of 
        twelve years. Both its format-free trade zone-and the stipulated deadlines 
        could not be met. In fact, when the negotiation of the Montevideo Treaty 
        of 1960 began, the original objective of the countries was to promote 
        preferential trade agreements, especially of sectoral scope, in order 
        to replace the bilateral agreements developed in the 1930s. This objective 
        had to be adapted to the requirements derived from the participation in 
        the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) and, in particular, 
        the prevailing interpretation of Article XXIV. (On the LAFTA and its subsequent 
        transformation into the LAIA see, among others, the publications by Félix 
        Peña: "The 
        LAFTA: Agenda for an anniversary", in La Nación newspaper, 
        March 13, 1979, on http://www.felixpena.com.ar/; 
        "Restructuring 
        the LAFTA: New ground rules for intra-zone trade?" in the Review 
        of Latin American Industrialists, April 1979, on http://www.felixpena.com.ar/; 
        "Argentina 
        and the process of restructuring the LAFTA", Working Group sponsored 
        by the CARI, coordinated by Félix Peña, October 15, 1979, 
        on http://www.felixpena.com.ar/; 
        "A 
        new LAFTA", in the Industrial Report Journal, April 1980, on 
        http://www.felixpena.com.ar/; 
        "Latin 
        America in the perspective of a desired and possible Argentina", 
        Notes for a Debate, June 1980, on http://www.felixpena.com.ar/; 
        "Argentina 
        in the Latin American context", Conference of a Colloquium held 
        in June 1980, published in the FAPES Journal of International Economic 
        Policy in February 1981, on http://www.felixpena.com.ar/; 
        "Future 
        prospects of the Brazil-Argentina relations", Brazilian Review 
        of International Policy, January 1981, on http://www.felixpena.com.ar/; 
        "A future outlook. Possible scenarios in international trade negotiations 
        ", WTO Chair - FLACSO Buenos Aires, September 2015; "Latin America 
        in an uncertain and turbulent world. Impacts on regional integration strategies 
        ", Journal of International Studies, Santiago, Chile, July 2017. 
        See also the publication by Vicente Garnelo in the book listed as recommended 
        reading of this newsletter). 
 The LAIA has at least two functions in its objective of developing "an 
        area of economic preferences". The negotiation of the Treaty of Montevideo 
        of 1980 had its epicenter in the XIX Conference of the Contracting Parties, 
        held in Acapulco, Mexico, in June 1980. (See the article by Vicente Garnelo, 
        "The Debate on the Integration Model of LAIA and its evolution" 
        in the book cited above. We participated in this conference and in the 
        negotiating process of the Treaty which created the LAIA, as ad-hoc legal 
        advisor to the LAFTA Secretariat).
 One function of the LAIA is to provide a legal framework for the conclusion 
        of agreements between all members (agreements of regional scope, Article 
        6), or at least between two or more of its member countries, but not all 
        of them (agreements of partial scope, Articles 7 to 14). In this case, 
        only the approval of the countries participating in the agreement is required. 
        Such agreements (regional or partial) must contribute to the development 
        of a common market (an objective without a definite deadline, to be achieved 
        "in a gradual and progressive way") between its member countries, 
        precisely because of the development of economic preferences.  The other function of the LAIA is to provide an institutional framework 
        to move forward, gradually and progressively, in the fulfillment of the 
        long-term goal, through the representative bodies of the States and the 
        role played by its General Secretariat. The governing bodies of the LAIA 
        are located in the city of Montevideo, Uruguay.  The first function helps to provide legal sustenance within and between 
        countries and also in the multilateral system of world trade (initially 
        the GATT and, since 1995, the WTO, either due to Article XXIV of the GATT-WTO 
        rules, or the much more flexible Enabling Clause approved in the Tokyo 
        Round, in 1979) to the trade preferences granted between member countries. 
        In the agreements of partial scope, such preferences extend only to the 
        participating countries, but eventually other or all members of the LAIA 
        may request participation as well. A general rule established by the Treaty is the most-favored-nation clause 
        (Article 44), which states that all member countries should be granted 
        any commercial advantage that is granted to non-member countries, or that 
        has not been granted to member countries within the framework of a partial 
        scope agreement. This rule was modified in June 1994 at the request of 
        Mexico, after its negotiation of NAFTA with the US and Canada. All member countries have a permanent representation in LAIA. Precisely 
        another function that can be fulfilled by the LAIA is to help build a 
        network of trade agreements and integration with other countries of the 
        region, complementing the actions developed at the bilateral level with 
        any of these countries. In this case, the General Secretariat can provide 
        technical support for the negotiations that are carried out.  In short, the LAIA can serve as an institutional framework that allows, 
        on the one hand, to provide legal coverage to agreements with elements 
        of trade preferences that are developed with all or some member countries, 
        eventually promoting them. On the other hand, it provides a space for 
        the interaction with other countries in order to foster and facilitate, 
        among other objectives, the development of trade and economic complementation. 
        This without prejudice to the fact that, over time, they might reach a 
        scope that encompasses more general and ambitious objectives (for example, 
        the common market) extending to all member countries.  For those companies interested in building or participating in transnational 
        networks in the area covered by the LAIA, the mentioned institutional 
        framework can serve as a source of information on the preferential actions 
        carried out in the region, and also as an ambit to promote governmental 
        agreements (of regional or partial scope) that are functional to their 
        objectives in other countries of the region. In particular, and if well interpreted, the instrument of partial scope 
        agreements can be functional to the web of sectoral networks of complementation 
        and productive integration (see the previously mentioned articles of the 
        Treaty of Montevideo of 1980 and Resolution CM2 of August 12, 1980). For 
        companies, especially SMEs, partial scope agreements and the economic 
        complementation modality can be useful instruments for a sectoral strategy 
        of complementation with companies from other LAIA countries.  If well-conceived, the agreements of partial scope -especially of economic 
        complementation and with sectorial or multisectorial reach- help achieve 
        a reasonable balance between two sometimes contradictory demands, coming 
        from the companies and the governments. The first one is the demand for 
        flexibility in the ground rules that are applied to develop sectoral productive 
        complementation strategies. The second is the demand for predictability 
        regarding the application of the corresponding ground rules agreed in 
        the agreements of partial scope, especially with regard to the stability 
        of the conditions of access to markets. The latter can be the most required 
        by the companies called to invest in view of the extended market generated 
        by any agreement of partial scope. The LAIA is, in this sense, an appropriate institutional framework to 
        advance in the development of economic complementation agreements, with 
        sectoral or multi-sectoral scope, for example, between Mercosur countries 
        and the Pacific Alliance, or between Mercosur countries, the Pacific Alliance 
        and Cuba. In this regard, the food and agriculture sector, including related 
        technologies and agricultural machinery, could be interesting examples 
        for countries and their business sectors. |  
   
    | 
        Albright, Madeleine, "Fascism. A Warning", Harper Collins 
          Publisher, 2018.
Ayres, Alyssa, "Our Time Has Come. How India is Making its Place 
          in the World", A Council on Foreign Relations Book, Oxford University 
          Press, New York 2018.
Bacchus, James, "Was Buenos Aires the Beginning of the End or 
          the End of the Beginnineg. The Future of the World Trade Organization", 
          Policy Analysis, CATO Institute, May 8, 2018, en https://www.cato.org/. 
          
Bassets, Marc, "La lucha por la supremacía del orden liberal", 
          Sección Internacional, "El País", 31 de mayo 
          2018, página 5, en https://elpais.com/. 
          
Boughton, James M., "Who´s in Charge? Ownership and Conditionality 
          in IMF-Supported Programs", IMF - Working Paper, WP/03/191, Washingtin 
          D.C. 2003, en https://www.imf.org/. 
          
Doig, Will, "High-Speed Empire Chinese Expansion and the Future 
          of SouthEast Asia", Columbia Global Reports, New York 2018.
Dressler, Andreas, "Investment Facilitation: A Practical Perspective", 
          ICTSD - WEF, The E15 Initiative, E-15 Investment Theme, Think Piece, 
          Geneva, May 2018, en http://e15initiative.org/. 
          
Economy, Elizabeth, C. "The Third Revolution. XiJinping and the 
          New Chinese State", A Council on Foreign Relations Book, Oxford 
          University Press, New York 2018.
Edwards, Sebastián, "American Default. The Untold Story 
          of FDR, the Supreme Court, and the Battler over Gold", Princeton 
          University Press, Princeton and Oxford 2018.
Farrow, Ronan, "War on Peace. The End of Diplomacy and the Decline 
          of American Influence", W.W.Norton & Company, New York - London 
          2018.
Fernández Saavedra, Gustavo; Chávez Álvarez, 
          Gonzalo; Zegada Claure, María Teresa, "La Bolivia del Siglo 
          XXI, nación y globalización. Enfoque internacionl y estudios 
          de caso", Programa de Investigación Estratégica en 
          Bolivia - PIEB, La Paz 2014.
Frieden, Jeffry, A., "Currency Politics. The Political Economy 
          of Exchange Rate Policy", Princeton University Press, Princeton 
          and Oxford, Princeton 2015.
Gao, Henry, "The WTO Dispute Settlement Mechanism: A Trade Court 
          for the World", IDA - ICTSD, Think Piece, April 2018, en http://e15initiative.org/. 
          
Garnelo, Vicente; Cruz e Creuz, Luis Rodolfo; Rojas Gómez, 
          Miguel, "50 Años del Proceso de Integración Latinoamericana. 
          Ensayos sobre la integración regional", ALADI, Montevideo 
          2011.
Garton Ash, Timothy, "El autoritarismo dentro de Europa", 
          Sección Opinión, "El País", 17 de mayo 
          2018, página 17, en https://elpais.com/. 
          
Gonzalez, Anabel, "Strengthening the Conditions for Global Cooperation 
          on International Trade", ICTSD, Policy Brief, Geneva, April 2018, 
          en https://www.ictsd.org/. 
          
Hufbauer, Gary, "No Winners in a US-China Trade War", East 
          Asian Forum, May 21, 2018, en http://www.eastasiaforum.org/. 
          
International Trade Centre (ITC), "What Sells in E-Commerce. 
          New Evidence from Asian LDCs", ITC in partnership with AliResearch, 
          Geneva 2018.
Isaacson, Walter, "Kissinger. A Biography", Simon & 
          Schuster Paperbacks, NewYork 2005.
Jahanbegloo, Ramin, "Tambores de Guerra", Sección 
          Opinión, diario "El País", 11 de mayo 2018, 
          página 18.
Kennedy, Andrew B., "The Conflicted Superpower. America's Collaboration 
          with China and India in Global Innovation", Nancy Bernkopf Tucker 
          and Warren I. Cohen Book on American-East Asian Relations, Columbia 
          University Press, New York 2018.
Kennedy, Andrew B., "How Trump is losing the high-tech fight 
          with China", East Asian Forum, May 27, 2018, en http://www.eastasiaforum.org/. 
          
Lehmann, Jean-Pierre, "Why a Rules-Based Multilateral Trade Régime 
          is Crucial for Growth and Peace", Forbes - Asia, May 4, 2015, en 
          https://www.forbes.com/. 
          
Le Thu,Huong, "Should Australia join ASEAN? Lessons from Vietnam", 
          East Asian Forum, May 10, 2018, en http://www.eastasiaforum.org/. 
          
López, Ociel Ali, "Un resultado multifuncional. Venezuela 
          y el debate postelectoral", en Nueva Sociedad 2018, mayo 2018, 
          en http://nuso.org/. 
          
Mahbubani, Kishore, "Beyond the Age of Innocence", Public 
          Affairs, New York 2005.
McBride, James, "What is the Trans-Pacific Partenership (TPP)", 
          Council on Foreign Relations, May 15, 2018, en https://www.cfr.org/. 
          
Marschik, Quinn; Min hee Jo, "China's integral role in Korean 
          War peace talks", East Asian Forum, May 27, 2018, en http://www.eastasiaforum.org/. 
          
Nasanovsky, Nadia, "Los servicios basados en el conocimiento, 
          en el podio exportador", Suplemento Pyme, "El Cronista", 
          24 de mayo 2018.
Neuwirth, Robert, "Stealth of Nations. The Global Rise of the 
          Informal Economy", Pantheon Books, New York 2011.
Nolte, Detlef; Mijares, Victor M., "La crisis de Unasur y la 
          deonstrucción de Sudamérica", diario "El Espectador", 
          Bogotá 23 de abril 2018, en https://www.elespectador.com/. 
          
Nun, José, "La reforma impositiva, una alternativa para 
          evitar el ajuste", Sección Opinión, "La Nación", 
          23 de mayo 2018, página 20, en https://www.lanacion.com.ar/. 
          
Oz, Amos, "Queridos Fanáticos. Tres Reflexiones", 
          Ediciones Siruela, Biblioteca Amos Oz, 2018.
Oz, Amos, "No he visto nunca un fanático con sentido del 
          humor", entrevista de 9J.C.Sanz a Amos Oz ,en Babelia, "El 
          País", 12 de mayo de 2018, en https://elpais.com/. 
          
Peña, Félix, "Requerimientos para navegar el nuevo 
          entorno regional", Suplemento Comercio Exterior, diario "La 
          Nación", 10 de mayo 2018, en https://www.lanacion.com.ar/. 
          
Porges, Amy, "Designing Common but Differentiated Rules for Regional 
          Trade Disputes", IDB - ICTSD - RTA Exchange, Washington D.C. - 
          Geneva 2018, en http://e15initiative.org/. 
          
Rozemberg, Ricardo; Gaya, Romina, "La relación Argentina-Chile. 
          Nuevos y viejos compromisos en un contexto diferente", CERA, Instituto 
          de Estrategia Internacional - IEI -, Buenos Aires, Abril 218.
Tenembaum, Ernesto, "Tierra de Locos. Porqué sufre tanto 
          la Argentina", Sección Internacional, diario "El País", 
          10 de mayo de 2018, página 10, en https://elpais.com/. 
          
Vieira Posada, Edgar, "Los actuales desafíos del proceso 
          de globalización", Colección de Bolsillo Acontecer 
          Mundial, CEPEG - Ediciones Universidad Cooperativa de Colombia, Bogotá 
          2016.
Weick, Karl E.; Sutcliffe, Kathleen M., "Managing the Unexpected. 
          Sustained Performance in a Complex World", Wiley & Sons, New 
          Jersey 2015. |  
   
    |  
        
 
   
    |  |   
    | Félix Peña Director 
        of the Institute of International Trade at the ICBC Foundation. Director 
        of the Masters Degree in International Trade Relations at Tres de Febrero 
        National University (UNTREF). Member of the Executive Committee of the 
        Argentine Council for International Relations (CARI). Member of the Evian 
        Group Brains Trust. More 
        information. |  
 
 |  |  |